Wednesday, February 05, 2025

"Type 3 conditional sentence"

Is this conditional sentence wrong? 

"If Jane had asked me, I would give her some money."

Glad to run into this example by Roger Berry in his 2021 book "Doing English Grammar : Theory, Description and Practice."

Berry was citing the above example from a test for teachers. The 'correct' answer, according to the test, and as you can guess, was: "If Jane had asked me, I would have given her some money." 

The so-called Type 3 Conditional Sentence!

Of course, depending on the context, and the speaker's intended meaning, "If Jane had asked me, I would give her some money" can be 'correct'!

Berry then used the term "the long-discredited three- or four-conditional approach" to describe the over-simplified and rigid classification of conditional sentences often promulgated in ESL textbooks. That totally resonates with me. 

Again, this highlights the importance of teacher language awareness. 

No comments:

Creating a WG presentation starting with an imported Google slides file

After the import, the interface on WG's 'create presentation' will look like Google Slides, but in fact is still in WG. You can ...