Friday, April 04, 2025

Using Deepseek to generate a rubric for students to evaluate their composition

 just tried Deepseek: 

My prompt:

please create a rubric to help junior secondary students to assess a composition that they have written. This rubric should be in the form of a table. The two criteria for self-assessing are grammatical accuracy, and quality of content. The 4 performance levels of unsatisfactory, satisfactory, good, and excellent. 


The result: 

Here’s a clear and concise rubric in table format to help junior secondary students self-assess their compositions based on grammatical accuracy and quality of content:

Criteria Unsatisfactory (1) Satisfactory (2) Good (3) Excellent (4)
Grammatical Accuracy Many errors in grammar, spelling, and punctuation, making the text difficult to understand. Some errors, but they do not severely disrupt understanding. Few errors; grammar and punctuation are mostly correct. Almost no errors; grammar, spelling, and punctuation are consistently accurate.
Quality of Content Ideas are unclear or off-topic; little to no supporting details. Some relevant ideas, but development is weak or repetitive. Clear and relevant ideas with some supporting details. Well-developed, engaging, and original ideas with strong supporting details.

How to Use the Rubric:

  • Students should read their composition carefully and assign a score (1–4) for each criterion.
  • They can reflect on areas for improvement based on the descriptors.

This rubric encourages self-assessment while keeping the criteria simple and measurable. Let me know if you'd like any adjustments!

https://poe.com/s/Wb6IS5IjoxCxHAy2mUaH


No comments:

Chatbots will modify their language according to users' stated English level

 我們從事English Language teaching的同工,今天利用chatbot去clarify一些language issue(例如"My favourite fruit is apples'是否OK),已經是家常便飯;那天突然想起,我們也可培養高小...